Comments for Sandwiches as a Measure of Economic Prosperity
- 7 replies
- Log In
- NNevs2011-01-04 06:29:00.000Z
So,not being forced to slave away at work until 23:30, nay, 01:00 is now a reason to condescend on Perth? Some people are just impossible to please.
^ Yes, I said rational reasons, if you want to make something of it, Heeris, we can adjourn to the carpark...
I think you may have the word "forced" confused with some other word, eg. just about any other. On the other hand, being forced to not work because you're only available after hours is a little frustrating.
It's nice that you've never had to try to find lunch during a Sunday shift in the middle of Perth or Fremantle, Nevs, or late on a weeknight, but yes, some people work then because they want to, or maybe they don't really but it's better than cutting classes, or maybe it's a necessary hit to take in an otherwise great job, or maybe they can trade some hours here or there so they can take time off when Perth is *actually open for business* to buy presents for orphans.
It's not slaving away, and it's not forced... it's just when some people work. And if you've ever gone to a movie on a Sunday or a weeknight, or your favourite science centre, or the zoo, or **ever** exchanged money for anything during those times you would classify as "slave time," you're being a bit of a hypocrite in exploiting those workers you're so valiantly defending now. And those people that you pay, they can't get any sandwiches, Nevs. None for them, because it would be **exploitation** of the poor sod who has to work the sandwich stand.
Incidentally, that post only makes the case for **WA**, not Perth... and that's if you love (a) doing radio astronomy research or (b) visiting a specific winery. Neither of those things involve *being within 100km of Perth*, let alone living here. In fact, Perth could disappear and it would make the radio astronomy *better*, unless there's residual radiation from a nuclear blast or something. But I agree that it's perfectly rational to claim that one of the best things about this state is that it's an isolated, radio-quiet plain.
My point still stands: Perth is commercially dead most of the time. Most people here, like yourself, think it's a good thing and should be legally enforced, so good for you.
As for being impossible to please, I thought the post made it abundantly clear that all that I require are sandwiches.
You both make me laugh. I wish more places were open later. I thought the extended trading hours might help with that, but it seems that most stores are still happy to stay shut. I've previously worked evening shifts up to past midnight, because, as Jason says, it isn't ideal but it's better than having to skip classes to work.
Now that stores are allowed to open later (not full deregulation but better than nothing) I guess I'll have to move on from blaming the government to blaming the generally conservative population of WA.
On a side note: my post about WA was never meant to claim that we're modern and cosmopolitan, just that we're about more than mining and that at least 3 of us are not racist rednecks. I still believe that to be true.
*I'll have to move on from blaming the government to blaming the generally conservative population of WA*
Well, on this issue, the first is merely an accurate representation of the second. Now, I *would* be happier to accept that I can't buy sandwiches simply because I'm a rare species of worker, and there's just not enough demand for it, but the laws we have mean we'll never know. It remains true that Perth is a ghost town outside 9-5 Mon-Sat, and whether that's through self-imposed laws or spontaneous communal aversion to commerce, I don't really care.
- DIn reply toUnknown [DwE4KFYW2]:Dave2011-01-12 10:08:00.000Z
For me, the purchase of sandwiches has more to do with: (a) it was too inconvenient to bring my lunch/dinner/miscellaneous atemporal snack, and (b) I have a mild, short-term sense of urgency with regard to my health.
This situation occurs mostly for me when traveling long distances, when you typically can't bring any food with you. Also, I always experience some form of malaise, which makes me look for whatever is likely to go softest on my intestines.
I posit, therefore, that the absence of sandwiches from Perth train station outside "normal" business hours is more an indicator that there aren't enough tourists arriving/leaving via the rail network. After all, long distance travel is one of the few human activities that seem to be almost completely decoupled from the influence of the sun.
However, neither of us has specified a causal relationship; it may be that the presence of sandwiches does not simply result from economic activity or tourism, but facilitates one or the other. So, there is a relatively simple way to test our hypotheses. If we were to open a 24/7 sandwich bar in Perth train station, we could then monitor (a) tourism levels, and (b) economic activity (minus the sandwiches and the tourists).
*This situation occurs mostly for me when traveling long distances, when you typically can't bring any food with you.*
It occurs for me every couple of days, simply because there's a low point at which I'd rather buy than make a sandwich. For most people I'd wager somewhere it's somewhere in between. The distribution of this is probably not narrow.
*long distance travel is one of the few human activities that seem to be almost completely decoupled from the influence of the sun*
Yes, but it's not the only one, and an activity doesn't have to be completely decoupled from daylight to have after-hours components.
*the absence of sandwiches from Perth train station outside "normal" business hours is more an indicator that there aren't enough tourists arriving/leaving via the rail network*
In Perth, tourism factors more into this because only a stranger to the city would think to go out. (I once had to explain to some German tourists on a Sunday morning that, no, it wasn't a holiday, no, there's no evacuation... this is just what Perth looks like on a Sunday morning. Of course, the rest of us know not to bother.)
Furthermore, tourism itself **is** economic acticity, and generally requires other businesses to be open, so sandwich availability as a result of tourism would *still* indicate economic activity (albeit by different mechanism than I proposed).
*If we were to open a 24/7 sandwich bar in Perth train station*
Funny you should say that, since it was only a couple of months ago that an enterprising Perth business owner wanted to expand his existing sandwich business to sell to very early morning commuters. Unfortunately it was illegal for him to do so. Experiment denied.
*However, neither of us has specified a causal relationship; it may be that the presence of sandwiches does not simply result from economic activity or tourism, but facilitates one or the other.*
Or, more to the point, that both are part of an economic ecosystem that comprises all sorts of dependencies and feedback, no single part of which can be isolated, but parts of which **can** be measured as indicators of overall health. People don't venture out after hours in Perth because they know everything is going to be closed. No businesses want to open after hours because (a) no-one will be out and (b) it's usually illegal.
If we removed (b) then business owners might try your experiment, and people would accept or reject it, and we know for sure. Either way, the observation remains: no sandwiches correlates with no activity.